While dog theft often makes headlines, feline theft is an underreported but steadily growing concern in the United States. Surprisingly, some cats are far more likely to be targeted than others—not because they’re reckless explorers or escape artists, but simply because they’re too fabulous for their own good.
Whether it’s their striking appearance, high resale value, or Instagrammable charm, certain cat breeds have unfortunately become magnets for pet thieves. These aren’t your average alley cats—these are high-demand, premium-priced felines that can fetch serious cash on the black market or be passed off as rescues to unsuspecting adopters. And yes, there’s data behind the drama.
So before you let your fluffy fashion model of a cat strut freely through the neighborhood or snooze on your unfenced patio, it’s worth knowing which breeds are most at risk. From exotic jungle lookalikes to lap-loving superstars, here are the top 7 cat breeds most likely to be stolen in the US—and what makes them so irresistibly swipeable.
1. Siamese
With their almond-shaped blue eyes, sleek coats, and striking color points, they often look like they belong in a luxury catalog. Their vocal and extroverted nature makes them unforgettable—and, unfortunately, easy to notice. Historically revered in Thailand, they’ve become one of the most recognizable cat breeds worldwide. Their popularity fuels high demand, which can tempt those with sticky fingers. Pet thieves know they can resell a Siamese quickly, especially if the buyer isn’t asking too many questions. If your cat sounds like it’s arguing with you in fluent sass, it might be a good time to double-check your door locks.
2. Bengal
There’s a jungle in their DNA. Bengals, with their stunning rosetted coats and energetic behavior, resemble small leopards who decided indoor life was the vibe. Originally bred from Asian leopard cats, Bengals have both the looks and the price tag of an exotic pet. They’re adored by active pet owners and Instagram influencers alike. That fame makes them a top-tier target for opportunists looking to cash in on rare, wild-looking felines. Bengals don’t just fetch attention—they fetch high resale prices on underground markets and sketchy online listings. Unless you want your cat starring in someone else’s TikTok, consider investing in a microchip and a security cam.
3. Persian
Grace doesn’t get much fluffier than this. Persians, with their long, luxurious coats and smooshy faces, are the royalty of the feline world. Known for their calm, affectionate demeanor and statuesque poses, they’re often viewed as the living embodiment of luxury. Thieves see dollar signs when they spot one napping in a sunbeam. They’re also quiet and less likely to bolt, which sadly makes them easier to grab. Add in grooming costs and breed prestige, and you’ve got a kitty with built-in value. Think of them as living heirlooms—just fluffier and more judgmental.
4. Maine Coon
Towering over most domestic cats, the Maine Coon is impossible to miss. They’re a dream for families and a dream-come-true for cat thieves. Despite their intimidating size, Maine Coons are usually too laid-back to resist an unfamiliar hand. Their friendly, dog-like behavior makes them easy to lure with treats or a little attention. Because they’re in such high demand (and command steep prices), they’ve become unfortunate favorites on pet theft watchlists. If your Maine Coon doubles as a fluffy roommate and emotional support system, keep an eye on both of you.
5. Russian Blue
Understated elegance defines the Russian Blue. Unlike some flashier breeds, they carry themselves with a quiet dignity and plush silvery-blue coats that shimmer in the light. Their rarity, combined with their hypoallergenic qualities, has made them a prized catch—literally. This breed isn’t just about looks; they bond deeply with their owners, often forming lifelong connections. That loyalty, however, doesn’t translate to wariness of strangers, which can be a risk. Thieves know they can market them as allergy-friendly pets to buyers who’ll pay a premium. If your cat looks like it belongs in a Bond film, maybe it deserves 007-level protection.
6. Ragdoll
Soft-hearted and softer-bodied, the Ragdoll is the teddy bear of cats. They earned their name from their uncanny habit of going limp when picked up—a trait that, sadly, makes them easier to steal. With their blue eyes, silky coats, and mellow nature, they’re adored for their companionship and aesthetic appeal. They’re also among the most expensive and sought-after breeds in the US. That combo makes them irresistible to thieves looking for a quick flip. Their trusting personality can be a vulnerability if they’re ever left unattended outdoors. It’s ironic that the cat who trusts everyone might need the most protection from people.
7. Abyssinian
Believed to be one of the oldest domesticated cat breeds, they exude an exotic elegance and athletic charm. Their ticked coat gives them a wild, fox-like appearance that turns heads everywhere they go. Combine that with their intelligence and energy, and you’ve got a cat that could star in an action movie. Thieves are drawn to their rare looks and lively nature, making them one of the most coveted “collector’s cats.” While they’re not as cuddly as a Persian or as vocal as a Siamese, their value is no less substantial. If your Abyssinian disappears, don’t be surprised if it turns up in a luxury loft… or a high-stakes cat show.